December 9, 2025
This article breaks down the difference between simply doing more reps and sets versus training with deliberate practice. You’ll learn how to design focused sessions that improve strength, technique, and muscle growth faster—with less wasted effort.
More sets and reps do not guarantee better results; quality and intent per rep matter more.
Deliberate practice means training at the edge of your ability with clear goals, feedback, and full attention.
You can turn any workout into deliberate practice by narrowing focus, tracking key metrics, and avoiding autopilot.
A mix of focused “practice sets” and simple volume works best for strength, muscle gain, and skill lifts.
Most lifters can gain more by doing slightly less, but better, than by constantly chasing more volume.
This article compares focused, deliberate practice to mindless volume using principles from skill acquisition research and strength training science. It explains key concepts, breaks down how they apply to different goals (strength, hypertrophy, fat loss, skill lifts), and gives practical frameworks and examples instead of a ranked list of exercises.
Most people assume more sets, more reps, and longer workouts automatically equal more progress. In reality, how you perform each rep has more impact than how many you do. Understanding deliberate practice helps you get better results in less time, avoid plateaus, and reduce injury risk.
Deliberate practice starts with specificity: knowing exactly what you’re trying to improve today. For example, adding 2.5 kg to your 5-rep max squat, cleaning up your deadlift start position, or keeping all sets within 1–2 reps of failure. Mindless volume often looks like wandering from machine to machine, copying a random workout, or just trying to get ‘tired’ without a clear performance goal.
Great for
In deliberate practice, your attention is on technique, tension, and execution every rep. You’re noticing bar path, breathing, tempo, and muscle engagement. Mindless volume means thinking about work, scrolling between sets, or chatting your way through reps. The same 3 sets of 10 can either refine your skill and stimulate growth or just burn time and energy depending on how present you are.
Great for
The difference between fast progress and long-term stagnation is rarely the program on paper; it is how deliberately each set is executed.
Most lifters can improve by slightly reducing total volume and increasing the number of genuinely focused, feedback-driven sets.
Deliberate practice and volume are not opposites—volume is a tool; it just becomes far more potent when paired with intentional reps.
Skill-heavy lifts (squats, deadlifts, Olympic lifts) benefit the most from deliberate practice, but even simple machines become more effective when executed with focus.
Decide what ‘success’ looks like before you warm up. Examples: hit all squat working sets at RPE 8 with consistent depth; maintain strict overhead press form with a 2-second pause at the bottom; or keep every hypertrophy set 1–2 reps from failure. One clear objective prevents your effort from scattering across too many goals.
Great for
Not every set needs maximum mental bandwidth. Choose 1–2 main lifts per workout as ‘practice lifts’ where you give full attention, collect feedback, and make adjustments. Accessory work can be simpler volume designed to accumulate fatigue safely. This lets you be highly deliberate without burning out mentally.
Great for
Strength responds best to relatively heavy loads, specific movements, and consistent technique. Deliberate strength practice means: focusing on 1–3 main lifts, using submaximal loads you can control, staying mostly within 1–3 reps of technical failure, and tracking bar speed or RPE. Mindless strength work often means maxing out too often, doing random heavy singles, or chasing fatigue instead of performance.
Great for
Muscle growth responds to mechanical tension and sufficient proximity to failure. You don’t need perfect form, but you do need consistent form and real effort. Deliberate hypertrophy practice includes controlling the eccentric, feeling target muscles work, avoiding momentum, and staying 0–3 reps from failure on most sets. Mindless hypertrophy often looks like rushing through high-rep sets, swinging weights, and guessing how hard you’re actually training.
Great for
If you’re spending 60–90 minutes in the gym, multiple times per week, but your main lifts haven’t moved in months, you likely have a volume problem—but not the one you think. You’re probably adding sets without increasing the quality of those sets. Progress plateaus when you repeat the same low-quality practice over and over.
Great for
If you walk into the gym and simply repeat last session’s numbers without any memory of what felt off or what you wanted to adjust, you’re missing the feedback loop. Deliberate practice feels like a continuation of a process; mindless volume feels like a fresh start every time—with the same results.
Great for
1) Squat: 3–5 deliberate ‘practice sets’ of 3–5 reps at RPE 7–8, video each top set, focus cue: depth and bar path. 2) Bench press: 3 practice sets of 4–6 reps, focus cue: pause and bar speed. 3) Accessories (rows, leg curls, triceps): 2–3 simpler volume sets near failure, less strict but still controlled. Total session: moderate volume, high focus on main lifts.
Great for
1) Main lift (e.g., incline bench): 2–3 deliberate sets of 6–8 reps with tempo focus and 1–2 reps in reserve. 2) Secondary compound (e.g., machine row): 3–4 sets of 8–12 reps, focusing on full range and tension. 3) Isolation work: 2–3 sets of 10–15 reps for biceps, triceps, shoulders, glutes. Here, deliberate practice is strongest on the first 1–2 exercises; accessories are higher-rep volume but still intentional.
Great for
Frequently Asked Questions
No. More volume helps up to a point, but only if the sets are hard enough and executed with decent form. Beyond your recoverable limit, extra sets add fatigue without more growth. For most people, 10–20 hard sets per muscle per week is plenty—provided those sets are deliberate, within a few reps of failure, and not rushed.
You don’t need to be intensely focused on every single set. For most lifters, giving full deliberate attention to 3–8 key sets per workout—usually on 1–2 main lifts—is enough to drive strong progress. The rest can be simpler volume, still controlled, but without the same level of analysis and feedback.
A coach helps, but is not required. You can create a feedback loop by filming lifts, using simple cues, and keeping a short training log. Over time, you’ll learn to spot technical errors and patterns in your performance. If you can, occasional check-ins with a coach can accelerate your learning and confirm you’re on the right track.
Beginners benefit enormously from deliberate practice because they’re building basic movement patterns. For them, deliberate practice might simply mean learning to squat to consistent depth, keep a neutral spine in hinges, and control the bar. They don’t need complex cues—just consistent focus on a few fundamentals each session.
You can absolutely keep some low-focus, ‘autopilot’ training if it helps you de-stress—as long as it’s safe. The key is to protect a portion of your week for deliberate practice on big, demanding lifts where progress matters most. Even 2–3 focused sessions per week can transform your results while leaving room for simpler, enjoyable workouts.
Deliberate practice in the gym is about turning sets into skillful, feedback-driven reps instead of mindless volume. Shift your focus from doing more to doing better: define clear goals, prioritize a few ‘practice sets’ each session, and track what you’re learning—not just what you’re lifting. Over time, you’ll see faster strength, muscle, and skill gains with less wasted effort and fewer injuries.
Track meals via photos, get adaptive workouts, and act on smart nudges personalised for your goals.
AI meal logging with photo and voice
Adaptive workouts that respond to your progress
Insights, nudges, and weekly reviews on autopilot
Deliberate practice lives in the ‘challenge zone’—hard enough that you must concentrate and adjust, but not so hard that form collapses. This often means working near technical failure, not just muscular failure. Mindless volume swings to extremes: either too light and easy to drive adaptation, or too heavy and sloppy, building bad habits and joint stress instead of useful strength.
Great for
Deliberate practice relies on feedback: video, coach cues, mirrors used intentionally, or internal cues like ‘knees out’ or ‘brace harder’. You make small changes set by set. Mindless volume rarely involves feedback; you repeat the same patterns without checking if they’re actually effective or safe, which locks in poor movement patterns over time.
Great for
With deliberate practice you track key performance metrics—load, reps, RPE (how hard a set felt), or technical notes like ‘lost tightness on last rep’. Mindless training often tracks only time in the gym or total volume, or worse, nothing at all. Without focused tracking, it’s hard to know if your added volume is actually moving you closer to your goal.
Great for
Before each set, pick one technical or effort cue: ‘drive knees out’, ‘brace then descend’, ‘slow eccentric’, or ‘full lockout and pause’. Trying to fix everything at once dilutes focus. Working one cue at a time upgrades your form over weeks and months without overwhelming you.
Great for
End a set when technique noticeably degrades, not when your ego wants one more ugly rep. This might mean stopping at 8 good reps instead of grinding to 11 with rounded back and bouncing. You still push hard—but the red line is form and control, not arbitrary rep targets.
Great for
After your hardest or most technical sets, jot down a short note: ‘hips shot up on last rep’, ‘bar drifted forward’, or ‘RPE 9, reduce 2.5 kg next week’. This creates a feedback loop from session to session, which is the heart of deliberate practice. You’re no longer repeating workouts—you’re iterating them.
Great for
When calories are low, your goal in the gym is to signal ‘keep this muscle’. Deliberate practice here means keeping strength and effort high even as energy drops, prioritizing big compound lifts and hard, controlled sets. Mindless fat-loss training often devolves into random circuits, light weights, and chasing sweat instead of maintaining performance—which risks losing muscle with the fat.
Great for
Olympic lifts, gymnastics skills, and complex movements benefit most from deliberate practice. That means many submaximal sets, each with one specific technical focus, plus frequent video review or coaching feedback. Mindless volume on skill lifts—heavy, sloppy reps done fatigued—ingrains poor patterns and increases injury risk.
Great for
If your main success metric is how sore, sweaty, or exhausted you are, you’re probably chasing sensations instead of outcomes. Deliberate practice sessions may be tiring, but their primary metric is performance: better technique, more load, more reps at the same load, or lower RPE at the same numbers.
Great for
Occasional rep breakdown happens, but if nearly every hard set turns into a technique disaster, you’re training beyond your current capacity. You’re practicing failing instead of practicing successful reps. Over time this teaches your body movement patterns that are inefficient and risky under load.
Great for
1) Olympic lift (e.g., power clean): 6–10 sets of 1–3 reps at light-moderate loads, each with one specific technical cue and frequent video review. 2) Strength movement (front squat): 3–4 sets of 3–5 reps at RPE 7–8. 3) Accessories: 2–3 simple sets for posterior chain and upper back. Most of the mental focus and feedback goes into the skill lift; volume is carefully controlled to avoid sloppy practice.
Great for
